I last did a post on Mustards Grill in June of 2008 for their 25th anniversary. I am overdue for an update on one of the oldest and most popular restaurants in the Napa Valley. Mustards Grill in Yountville has stood the test of time. Now in its 31st year, it is as popular as ever. It is still owned and operated by the fabulous chef, Cindy Pawlcyn. We visited this past Wednesday for lunch. The place was jumping with wine country visitors and the locals, including some winemakers. Not much had changed at Mustards Grill since our previous visit. The menu is still much the same and the food is as tasty as always. The BBQ pork sandwich on the menu (pulled pork, slow cooked) is fantastic with the pork soaked in what Cindy calls her Ooo-Eee sauce. Wow, what flavors! That’s what I had for lunch and it was delicious. The daily fish tostada is another favorite. Crab cakes are also divine. One thing I like about Mustards Grill and Cindy’s other restaurant in the Napa Valley, Cindy’s Backstreet Kitchen in St. Helena, is the wine list. The wine list is extensive with a generous focus on Napa Valley wines. Perhaps even better are the prices of the wine. Unlike many other Napa Valley restaurants, the markup on most of the wines is quite reasonable. Since our last visit, the Mustards Grill gardens have been upgraded to an extensive degree. Planter boxes are filled with all types of veggies and herbs, bringing the freshest ingredients to the table. I love the Padron Pepper planter box that must have 50 plants with these small, scrumptious Spanish peppers. A sign on the Padron planter box reads “Padron Peppers, Que Rico!” I own the Mustards Grill Cookbook and I can tell you from experience the Mustards cookbook is true to the food served at Mustards Grill. Some of my favorites in the book are Grilled Figs with Pancetta, Achiote-Marinated Chicken Breasts, and the BBQ Pork Sandwich pictured above. Visit the Mustards Grill Website for the restaurant hours of operation. Don’t miss it when you are traveling in the Napa Valley wine country.
Mustards Grill Slide Show
More information on Mustards Grill and Yountville
- Other restaurants in the Yountville area
- Best wineries to visit on Highway 29
- Lodging in Yountville – the best
- Buy Cindy Pawlcyn’s Mustards Grill Cookbook
She runs a first class operation with very professional service and food presentation. Always a joy to eat there.
I see your blue and white striped shirt in the window refection.
Yes, you spotted me. Good observation skills.
Simply one of the best, and most enduring restaurants on the planet !
Thanks for the nice write -up on Mustards Grill. It’s been years since Mike and I ate there. Now we will make it a destination next time we are in the Napa area. The photos made my stomach growl!
Yes, so much fun there. Thanks for reading the article.
Joe and Janelle